Switching from Topsolid to Solidworks - > the pitfalls?

Hi cartoonists.

I just joined a company that works under TopSolid.
They have to upgrade the software ... and the question arises whether to do this upgrade or to switch to Solidworks (basically, it's now or never!)

So, in order to see more clearly, what are the points to keep in mind to make the decision?
For those who have made the switch, have you encountered any unexpected problems?

And finally, what about the database? Is there a kind of " large mixer " that allows everything to be switched to STEP?

1 Like

Hello,
I have several questions that come to me quickly:

  • What is the volume of data?
  • What is the number of files?
  • What is the number of users?
  • Are there any problems with TopSolid?
2 Likes

Hello coin37coin,

I found a comparison " Topsolid vs Solidworks " on the net.
Maybe it can help you =>https://www.logiciels-informatiques.info/topsolid-vs-solidworks-quel-logiciel-de-cao-choisir/

And that too =>https://cadexchanger.com/topsolid-to-solidworks/

And that=>https://forum.mycad.visiativ.com/t/passage-de-solidworks-a-topsolid/106229?locale=fr&lang=fr

@+.
AR.

1 Like

The question was asked at our company 15 years ago since we had 2 separate design offices (following a company takeover) on TopSolid and SW.
We had weighed the pros and cons of the 2 softwares.
For Topsolid:
The advantages were CAM (used for the mecha part of our machines), faster for large drawings but less easy to modify from an assembly.
The defect of switching to the topsoli 7 version (from memory) broke the whole (catastrophic) principle of topsolid sketches (the famous concatenated sketch was mandatory)
For SW easier to hire, more user-friendly very simple sketch.
In addition, we started at that time to develop automatic launches under SW thanks to the visiativ utility (non-existent under topsolid) and then in SW macro.

The solution was therefore naturally SW.

2 Likes

We are 2 users. For the volume, I can't say too much... especially since it works a lot per case (one-shot). And as a result, I'm not even sure that a full transfer is necessary.

It's not really a problem with TopSolid. I'm starting with it, so obviously I'm fumbling around a lot... but my colleague who has been working with it for years seems to be at the same level. So, while we're at it, we wonder if we wouldn't be better off going back to things we know.
That said, it seems to be a good software of methods but not of design ... and I tear out the little hair I have left on the drawings

Top @A_R , I'm going to go read this

I don't know Topsolid

It's interesting to have to start implementing software these days. A lot of information available.
If I have an opinion to give it is to plan a PDM with a dedicated server, even with 2 designers. If PCs are powerful in the case of large assembly and therefore of drawing greedy in computer resources.
In the case of small assembly why not SW is up to the task and the machines will run easily.

If not, why Topsolid and SW, but not another such as inventor. I discovered it 3 years ago (after 20 years of SolidWorks) and to tell the truth, it's now the software that runs easily on any PC, even laptop. Very easy to upgrade when you know SW.

2 Likes

I practiced it ... 15 years ago now. So, it goes back a bit far in memory.
The idea of changing was to have a software known to the designers in place. If you want to do a training course and not know too much about the software, you might as well stay with TopSolid: at least the database is created :wink:

2 Likes

It's true that sudden change is not always well received.
But it's a fairly easy software to get to grips with. Not too resource-intensive.
I just finished a project where the model was quite big, and SolidWorks rammed, on the other hand inventor did well. Well the Pcs with 32 of RAM and a sublayer of m...
But indeed if you don't feel the change through the guys, it's not worth worrying. It's still a most important tool being the design.
I rather like to say that it is in the design method that you have to spend your energy

Completely agree.
And precisely, from my 1 month of experience, TopSolid is not a design software.
He probably does a lot of things very well for machining, but for the design, there are too many failures and resourcefulness for it to be " fluid "

1 Like

He probably does a lot of things very well for machining, but for the design, there are too many failures and resourcefulness for it to be "fluid"

It's good to know

Can you detail your feelings?
It's interesting. :wink:

So, where do you start?

Parts:

  • When adding matter, a new body is created. You then have to go through a Boolean operation to tell it that it is the same body
  • No extrusion by removing material (one hole) in both directions, you have to make one direction and then a 2nd function for the opposite direction
  • Creation of a rather limited and tedious plan/axis
  • No configurations possible
  • An inverted construction tree. The last functions are at the top of the tree and not at the bottom (haaa, habits ^^)
  • In sketch mode, if you click on an element, you don't see what the constraints are associated with it. So, it's a practical way when you need to change things
  • Selecting a plane in the building tree does not predispose that it is selected for the creation of a sketch.

Assemblies:

  • Non-intuitive and limited constraints
  • No movement of the parts in relation to each other, except to go through the " mechanism " box. Which is like making a short film (if I understood correctly)
  • To fix on planes / axes / points, you have to enter the room and " publish " what interests you. This is not done by default and it is very frustrating
  • No configurations possible there either.

MEP

  • To dimension from a plane / axis / point, you have to " publish " in the room so that it is visible in the MEP
  • Once the plane/axis/point is visible, you have to go and hide them in the views where they are not needed
  • Tolerance system that consumes a lot of energy in terms of mouse clicks
  • If changes are made in the room, the dimensions do not follow in the MEP. Forced to repoint everything
  • A quote in == that comes out of another time (e.g. =24= )
  • On a dimension between flat and Ø, it necessarily goes through the center of the Ø. Forced to go through construction to have on a tangency of the Ø (no mini or maxi like in Sldws)

In a rather general way,

  • Lots of clicks to make
  • I don't find the rotation by click in the middle " natural " (but that's quite a personal feeling)
  • an online help service that is leeeent. You have to wait about 24 hours before you get an answer
  • a really not great measurement system (to get the weight, you have to go to a special mode and go to a submenu)

The +:

  • A PDM included
  • A dimension symmetry function, quite well done

There is probably something else, but I've only been using it for a month :wink:

4 Likes

Thank you for this complete and interesting feedback.
Beautiful day

1 Like

Hello;

To answer this question, yes it seems that there is a great " Blender ":
https://help.topsolid.com/7.19/fr/TopSolid'Design/TopSolid/Pdm/UI/Items/MultiExportDocumentWithConversionCommand.htm?utm_source=qwant&utm_medium=referral&utm_campaign=ai_chat

But here a question arises about the change of software, if you export your TopSolid creations in Step, you will end up with "dead " bodies.

So it all depends on the solution considered: you stay in " STEP " on these elements, or you plan to rebuild them with Solidworks functions (more or less easy depending on the complexity (function recognition is not always ... relevant).
Not to mention the training of other designers, if there are any, on Solidworks, for them too it is a big change.

Looking (diagonally, I admit) at the TopSolid tutorials, it seems that the construction of the holes is still relatively similar to that of Solidworks...
https://help.topsolid.com/7.19/fr/TopSolid'Design/index.htm#utm_source=qwant&utm_medium=referral&utm_campaign=ai_chat&t=TopSolid%2FCad%2FDesign%2FUI%2FDrillings%2FOperations%2FDrillingCommand.htm&rhsearch=perçage&rhhlterm=perçage&rhsyns=%20
Seeing this, I wonder about the " quality " of current realizations... but maybe I'm wrong...

1 Like

We are only 2 cartoonists. And the other one is also from Sldws: he complains almost more than me, and that's already a pretty high bar :rofl:
All this to say that we are not going for a big change in user habits... see that the change is desired :slight_smile:

It's not so much the quality of the current achievements as the inefficiency of the software that is at issue. There are a few points where it's not bad and has some good ideas. But overall, we lose a lot of time in design, workaround problems or unplanned functions. Not to mention the drawings that are completely unstable and lose all link with the 2D during modifications.

Indeed, that's a lot of dead body. And it's also a point that bothers me a lot ... if it's not to say THE point that bothers me.

You're talking about Solidworks there, aren't you?

:rofl::grin: :stuck_out_tongue_winking_eye:

3 Likes