Which CAD software should I choose?

Hi all

Launching my professional activity in February, I will have to invest in a 3D design software. I specify that I studied on Solidworks, and am used to "tinkering" on Solidworks. I was planning to work with Solidworks, but when I learned about the prices, for the use I will have of it I wonder if it is really worth it. (I don't use the 3D simulation interface, production line management... etc)

So I'm coming to you to find out which software to get, because I know that there are cheaper ones.

Here is my use:

- 3D Design/Modeling

- Drawing

I would also need the equivalent of a task scheduler, or order management of several files, in relation to this software. This is also mandatory because I will have several thousand JPEG images to produce in relation to my different designs.

I don't do aeronitics, robotics or anything else, I'm a stonemason, and use this 3D software to design my parts, generate images to provide them to customers, and print my scale 1 jigs.

Do you have an idea of the software that could suit me? Knowing that I still want it to be professional, and easy to use.

 

Thank you

 

Hello

Maybe here: http://cf2i.fr/logiciels/smartsketch/

This one seems too simple to me, not enough tools, not enough freedom... etc

I would like a software with almost the same Solidworks functions: Creation of material, removal of material, adding constraints... etc

see https://www.onshape.com/

@+

1 Like

@gt22, I tested, and yes really well, ..... but with a very good internet connection

and be careful in public version the drawings are accessible to all so no privatization

2 Likes

If SolidWorks suits you and you're used to it, why would you want to change?

You will have to get used to the new software again (risk of wasting time).

For the cost, indeed it's not cheap (maintenance included), but hey it's in the market price compared to the competition and for equal quality.

Negotiate with the reseller, and try to find, at the same time, subsidies since you are creating your business.

3 Likes

What do you think of "Top Solid" and "SolidEdge"? They cost an average of €1500 per year.

Inventor according to some acquaintances told me that it looked like Solidworks and was much cheaper than Solidworks.

Yes I am entitled to some small help, I agree on the principle, but in the other direction, paying for a software to use only 1/4 of these functions... I don't think it's great either.

So if there is ever a similar software, and cheaper, I'm a taker, and I'd prefer to put this 6000 euros for something else ^^.

After that, if I don't find anything better, I won't have much of a choice, I'll stay at Solidworks^^

1 Like

Be careful with the autodesk suite, they go on rental so almost 3000 € per year without owning the software (premium pack with autocad inventor rendering etc )

Ok ok, I just saw that there was ZW3D, you know?

Hello

We offer a "Start-up" program with significant discounts on SOLIDWORKS for startups.

Send us an inquiry here: https://www.my-cad.fr/rappel-immediat/
We will present the program to you in detail.

Good evening:)

7 Likes

Hello

Creo Element/Direct Modeling is free.

More information, on the link below:

http://www.ptcfrance.com/cad/elements-direct/modeling/express

S.B

SW in your case, the base rate is indeed around 6k€ (minus the discount Clementine is talking about, around 1k€ according to another discussion on this forum).

Since it's not to communicate with your customers, you can possibly skip the 1500€ annual maintenance, which allows, among other things, to benefit from the new versions.

The Autodesk rental solution can be interesting by allowing you to benefit from a normal price for your basic solution and by renting the rendering modules just when you need them. It also avoids having to take out a large amount of money all at once. But, indeed, when you stop paying you no longer have any tools. This is to be taken into consideration, possibly by generating a stp/iges model of each part to possibly be able to change software.

Hello

You can take a look at DesignSpark Mechanical.

Hello

I work for the company ZWFRANCE and we sell the ZW3D software, which is a software quite comparable to Solidworks (many of our customers worked on Solidworks and really appreciate our software because it is similar and much cheaper: 1250€ HT for the first price, and it is a perpetual license... no rental ;) )  
You can call us on 02 40 09 50 00 if you have any questions (we do free demos), and you can also test the software for free for 30 days: https://www.zwfrance.fr/zw3d/ => click on "download"

Given your experience with SolidWorks and you know it's a good fit, the easiest way would be to go with it. After all, it's true that for a craftsman it's not cheap even with the discount possible via the "Jeune pousse" program offered by Clémentine.

Hello

 

You say that you are a sculptor (so very special and artistic shapes) then I tell you that all the Solidworks, inventor, PTC and other software are not very suitable.

Unless you're a super ace of the surface (just thinking about it I have hair growing in the cranial cavity)

Chose a software like Zbrush which was not very expensive or Blender which was free or Rhino 3D.

Obviously this requires a certain investment in training but you will brilliantly save your time in the realization of your models.

I use MODO 901 which does great things but requires quite heavy training. I use it for sculptures and ceramic vases and rigging from solidworks models.

Kind regards