Hello, could you inform me?

In our design office, we use SOLIDWORKS version 2012 and CATIA version V5R19 software.

Is it possible to recover and open SOLIDWORKS sldasm, sldprt and sldraw files without data loss?

I know the principle of saving these solidworks files in STEP or IGES and then opening them in CATIA but a lot of data is lost.

Isn't there a module or gateway to solve this problem and create compatibility and conversion between the files of these two softwares?

If this module exists, can it be grafted onto CATIA V5R19 or SOLIDWORKS 2012 and what is the price?

Thank you in advance for the answer

Sincere greetings

D.CUNAT

2 Likes

Hello

 

Datakit offers this type of interface in both directions.

 

http://www.lynkoa.com/store/fr/logiciels/convertisseurs.html

 

@+

 

5 Likes

Hello

 

from memory there is a module for Solidworks to import catia (I don't know the exact name but it's something like cat importer) on the other hand it doesn't keep the tree of the parts and you only end up with imported solids. 

 

To my knowledge, it's impossible to keep the creation tree from one software to another, but I may be wrong. 

Hello

 

SW Premium can recognize the functions used, not knowing Catia, I don't know if the reverse is true.

 

Then I invite you to check out this topic: http://www.lynkoa.com/questions/conversion-fichiers-3d

 

A+

 

1 Like

@

Jose-accessa

 

The trick to recognize the functions of solidworks doesn't work very well I think. 

@TontonVelu the Feature Works feature works very well on "prismatic" or sheet metal type parts, as long as you sometimes guide it a little. On the other hand, it does not work at all on shaped parts.

@Jose-accessa this feature is available in SolidWorks Pro and therefore Premium too.

 

@+

2 Likes

See this link below

http://www.datakit.com/fr/cross_manager.php

 

PS: @ Coyotte I hadn't seen your answer

 

@+

1 Like

It is possible to convert CAD files while preserving the build history with the 3D_Evolution conversion software. 

 

http://www.lynkoa.com/store/fr/logiciels/cao-3d/3d-evolution.html

 

Here is a video showing how to recover the "intelligence" of a file from CatiaV5 in NX in automatic mode.

 

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cUFXGAwI1fs

 

 

2 Likes

As Jerome (who I think must work at CoreTechnologie :P says), there is the 3D_Evolution software but also Cadfix, Datakit or the catiaV5 solidworks translator add-on (cited on another post by Fthomas).

 

After that, nothing is free and it's often even rather expensive, basically it's professional, for pros... So think twice before investing...

 

Hello

As far as I know, it is really up to scratch,

A few years ago, I looked into it seriously

because we had AUTODESK software (INVENTOR, and AUTOCAD, SOLIDWORKS, CADKEY, CIMCAD and CATIA (V4 and V5)

in solid 3D, the only viable format is the STEP (IGES is only valid for surface files (CATIA V5), and we lose the tree structure

Despite everything, the parts must remain relatively simple (difficulty with parts such as cylinder heads, or aircraft engine blades for example)

 

in 2D, it's the DXF, although now all software is transformed into DWG

The elements inside the file must remain simple

(risk of loss of dimension, hatching, splines etc...) that are specific to each software

 

I have already tried the DATAKIT software, very expensive for efficiency, they are unable to recover an engine cylinder head for example

because our problem was the recovery of customer files which were 90% CATIA files

the only solution was to clean up the CATIA file and simplify it as much as possible to transfer it

 

1 Like

this link to read

 

http://worldcadaccess.typepad.com/blog/2013/06/dassault-wont-give-you-this-free-solidworks-catia-xlator-but-cce-will.html

 

@+

Hello

I have the impression that this subject is endless, the problem has always existed and, in my opinion, will continue for quite some time.

When will the universal format be available?

sorry I'm in grumpy mode... ;D

Thomas

 

3 Likes

In addition for two software from the same publisher.....  

3 Likes

At the same time, when you see that the SW 2013 files don't open in 2012, you quickly understand the commercial side of Dassault, so from there to create formats compatible between 2 softwares.... it's not tomorrow that it will change :/

 

 

1 Like

from the same publisher, certainly tontonvelu ...  But the graphics engine of the two software (CATIA and Solidworks) is completely different and that's the problem!

If we take a software like SolidEdges for example that uses the same engine as Solidworks, we have a much higher file compatibility although the function creation tree is still not there.

 

2 Likes

@Jose-accessa

The solidworks 2013 file opens in solidworks 2012 SP5 ;o)

It just goes to show that by dint of asking one day we end up seeing interesting new things arrive

2 Likes

Well, that's great news!

Thank you @fthomas for this little information which can greatly improve the work!

Business is business!

@Jose-accessa: You have to take the time to read the WhatsNews when the versions are available, or come and participate in the Kickoffs organized in several cities of France. This is an opportunity for you to learn about what's new in the next version and to meet other users in your region.

Register HERE , it's free.

 

Kind regards

3 Likes

@jmsavoyat, I'll be at the Lyon kickoffs in October :)

1 Like